- A new analysis found that highly engineered consumables could be just as habit-forming as tobacco products.
- The study authors found that UPFs are engineered to maximize pleasure and speed up the delivery of reinforcing components.
- The “addictive” property of these foods implies they fuel compulsive consumption and interfere with natural hunger cues.
- Study contributors suggest that UPFs could be governed by controls similar to those for tobacco products.
Currently, there is no single agreed-upon definition of ultraprocessed foods. Certain experts classify them as products that include components you would not find in a personal cupboard, such as emulsifiers and additives.
A lot of dietitians rely on the NOVA system to identify UPFs. This describes foods that are “formulations of components, mostly of exclusive industrial use, typically made by a series of factory processes and methods.”
A recent analysis featured in The Millbank Quarterly proposed that UPFs could be just as habit-forming as cigarettes.
“I concur with these findings, as ultra-processed foods are intentionally formulated to be incredibly tempting to the majority of people,” stated a weight loss specialist not affiliated with the study.
Data from 2023 estimates that more than 73% of the foods available in the United States is classified as ultraprocessed.
“Tobacco and UPFs are not simply whole foods but scientifically formulated delivery systems engineered deliberately to optimize biological and psychological reinforcement and repeated intake,” wrote the new study’s authors.
Can UPFs Addictive?
The review synthesized data from addiction, historical health policy, and nutrition to pinpoint textural and compositional characteristics that increase the rewarding nature of both tobacco and ultraprocessed foods.
“It’s not all people is ‘addicted’’ to such products, but for a sizable group, they trigger typical addiction-like patterns: intense desires, loss of control, and persistent consumption despite harmful consequences,” explained a preventive cardiology dietitian.
“These foods are intentionally designed with processed carbohydrates, extra oils, salt, and flavor enhancers to maximize reward and ongoing intake, and the industry employs aggressive marketing tactics, particularly targeting young people,” she stated.
The authors focused on five key areas:
- delivery speed
- pleasure-based design, or designing foods to be extremely pleasurable
- dose optimization
- widespread availability
- misleading changes, or “health washing”
They found that, like cigarettes, ultraprocessed foods are fine-tuned to provide the optimal amount of sugar.
“Refined carbohydrates stimulate the feel-good chemical production via the vagus nerve, whereas lipids achieve this through fat detection in the gut,” the authors wrote.
“… UPFs with significant amounts of refined carbohydrates and added fats are some of the most strongly reinforcing substances in the modern diet. It is key that this processed carb and fat combination is rarely found in whole foods.”
How such products rapidly deliver “pleasure-inducing” chemicals to the mind makes them potentially addictive, in a comparable way to tobacco.
The paper explained that while cigarettes are engineered to provide nicotine quickly, UPFs are formulated to be broken down and absorbed quickly, as they typically have minimal dietary fiber. This allows for the system to process lipids and carbohydrates faster.
Authors also point out that ultraprocessed foods provide intentional intense tastes that fade quickly and mouthfeels that melt in your mouth. This all helps to deliver more dopamine and prompts individuals to consume additional amounts.
‘Wellness Branding’ in Tobacco, UPFs
According to the analysis, both the cigarette and food sectors have long used a tactic called “health washing.”
This refers to when goods are marketed and reformulated to create an perception of reduced harm while maintaining the essential of their properties.
This tactic in the cigarette sector became popular in the mid-20th century with the advent of filters on smokes.
These were sold as protective innovations that would catch harmful substances prior to they entered the lungs. In reality, these tips offer little significant protection.
However, people often adapted by inhaling deeper or smoking more frequently, which offset any decrease in harmful intake.
Food manufacturers has taken a similar approach. It uses labels like “low fat” or “sugar-free” to market UPFs.
Yet, these foods still contain the same addictive formulations. The problem is that these reformulations offer a superficial impression of wellness while the item’s addictive structure and health risks persist unchanged.
Ought Ultraprocessed Foods Face Controls?
The authors noted at the conclusion of their review that food and tobacco are fundamentally different.
Nevertheless, they cautioned that certain ultraprocessed foods function like highly optimized products rather than real nourishment. They recommended that health regulations should reflect this reality.
“Cigarettes provides a cautionary tale, and tobacco control provides a source of hope,” the researchers wrote.
Due to regulations, smoking levels in the United States have fallen and have “altered public perception of smoking and eroded confidence in the sector.”
“I believe increased awareness regarding the negative impact of ultra-processed foods is essential to lower general consumption and enhance public health. The strategies employed to curb cigarette use have been effective and could be a helpful blueprint for ultra-processed foods as well,” said one specialist.
“It is not my view ultraprocessed foods should be regulated exactly as tobacco, but they certainly deserve more robust, tobacco-inspired policies: marketing restrictions, clear front-of-package labeling, stricter rules on health claims, and limits in schools or hospitals,” added another nutrition professional.
The researchers reminded people that lightly altered and unprocessed foods have sustained human health for thousands of years.